Law Dork with Chris Geidner

Share this post

The Supreme Court doesn't like accountability

www.lawdork.com

The Supreme Court doesn't like accountability

Also: Anti-LQBTQ bills are being introduced all over, and three anti-trans bills already passed Utah's Senate. And: Florida is banning books and threatening teachers.

Chris Geidner
Jan 23
18
2
Share this post

The Supreme Court doesn't like accountability

www.lawdork.com

Photo by Joshua Woods on Unsplash

The Supreme Court released its first opinion of the term on Monday, a unanimous decision in favor of the government in a case about the statute of limitations in a veteran’s benefits case.

Justice Amy Coney Barrett had the opinion for the court.

The most notable thing about Monday’s opinion is how long it took us to get the first opinion of the term. Ultimately, it’s not all that important, but given that the court is hearing fewer cases these days, it is notable.

The court is doing less on its merits docket, even as it continues to take more actions on its shadow docket and prevent accountability for the justices or scrutiny of the court’s actions — including deciding against livestreaming opinion announcements. You won’t be able to hear Barrett’s announcement of her opinion until at least October, when the court begins its next term and turns over the audio from this term to the National Archives.

Sure, that’s not all that important for Monday’s decision, but imagine the affirmative action decision came down today, and Chief Justice John Roberts read a ruling from the bench that ended race conscious admissions policies in America.

If that happened — and it’s definitely possible that exact thing could happen sometime in the coming months — imagine how much more effective coverage of the opinion would be if news entities were able to play audio of Roberts reading the decision.

Yes, the words are there on the paper nearly immediately, and that’s “the law.” And, yes, people other than the justices can then explain what the ruling means and how it will effect people. But that immediately removes the justices from their decisions.

Additionally, the failure of the court to livestream its opinion announcements as it does its arguments simply takes a piece of governing that could be available to the public and hides it away for several months, until its effective use is primarily for researchers or historians.

Imagine how much more accountability the justices could face for their decisions if their announcement of those decisions was readily and immediately accessible to the public.

Of course, the justices realize that, too. And that’s likely why the decision audio isn’t livestreamed.

Law Dork with Chris Geidner is independent, reader-supported legal and political journalism that seeks to hold government and other public officials accountable. Support this reporting by becoming a free or paid subscriber today.

ANTI-LGBTQ — PRIMARILY, ANTI-TRANS — BILLS: State legislatures are convening, and their members are proposing many anti-LGBTQ bills. As with last year, many of these specifically focus on transgender people. Many of them focus on transgender people’s ability to obtain necessary health care.

The ACLU has a tracker up that, as of this writing, identifies 161 anti-LGBTQ bills introduced already this year.

From the ACLU’s “Mapping Attacks on LGBTQ Rights in U.S. State Legislature” website

Of course, many of these bills will not pass. But, as others have noted, the fact that many won’t pass does not mean, in this environment, that they shouldn’t receive attention.

In an article at them, Oliver Haug spoke with several of the leading advocates, researchers, and writers on anti-trans legislation about the upcoming legislative sessions. The ACLU’s Chase Strangio told Haug:

One of the sad realities is, almost every Republican-led state has passed a sports ban. So I think we'll see a shift in momentum to the health bans.

We are seeing that already, as Erin Reed reported on Jan. 20:

Erin In The Morning
Utah, Mississippi, and Florida Race To Ban Care For Trans Youth
Read more
2 months ago · 26 likes · 1 comment · Erin Reed

Utah’s S.B. 16, a bill that would restrict or bar transgender minors from receiving necessary health care, was passed by the Senate last week and was introduced in the House on Monday.

A bill to bar birth certificate changes for transgender minors (S.B. 93) and a bill forcing school districts to provide information to parents about their children’s gender identity (S.B. 100) both also have passed the Utah Senate. They, too, were introduced in the House on Monday.

A rally is scheduled to take place in Utah on Tuesday in opposition to the anti-trans legislation.

Twitter avatar for @ErinInTheMorn
Erin Reed @ErinInTheMorn
Hey everyone! Activists in Utah are sharing with me that there will be a rally for trans rights at the Capitol on January 24th. The banning of HRT and blockers for trans youth is moving quickly there. Please travel and show up and make your voice heard.
No body is illegal. Jan 24 at 12PM
Fight for trans kids at the capitol.
4:40 PM ∙ Jan 22, 2023
2,086Likes785Retweets

FINALLY, A FLORIDA UPDATE: From Judd Legum at Popular Information, yet another disturbing story about what Gov. Ron DeSantis is doing to education in Florida.

Popular Information
Florida teachers told to remove books from classroom libraries or risk felony prosecution
Teachers in Manatee County, Florida, are being told to make their classroom libraries — and any other "unvetted" book — inaccessible to students, or risk felony prosecution. The new policy is part of an effort to comply with new laws and regulations championed by Governor Ron DeSantis (R). It is based on the premise, promoted by right-wing advocacy grou…
Read more
2 months ago · 220 likes · 109 comments · Judd Legum

Thanks for reading Law Dork. Subscribe now.

2
Share this post

The Supreme Court doesn't like accountability

www.lawdork.com
Previous
Next
2 Comments
Ian Mark Sirota
Jan 23

Sigh.

Is there ANY good news out there??????

Expand full comment
Reply
Jean in Florida
Jan 23

Also note that Florida Governor Ron DeSantis is asking state universities for information about students who received gender affirming treatment. Unbelievable.

Expand full comment
Reply
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Chris Geidner
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing