Law Dork

Share this post

Federal judge puts Idaho schools bathroom ban on hold before new school year starts

www.lawdork.com

Discover more from Law Dork

The Supreme Court, law, politics, and more.
Over 21,000 subscribers
Continue reading
Sign in

Federal judge puts Idaho schools bathroom ban on hold before new school year starts

"School districts may choose how to organize their bathrooms," U.S. District Judge David Nye ruled. "[T]he State of Idaho will not be mandating that decision at this time."

Chris Geidner
Aug 12, 2023
57
Share this post

Federal judge puts Idaho schools bathroom ban on hold before new school year starts

www.lawdork.com
8
Share

A federal judge in Idaho on Thursday issued an order putting the state’s new law banning transgender students from using the restroom in accordance with their gender identity on hold, just days before the start of school in the state.

“S.B. 1100 will not be in effect when school starts on August 16, 2023,” U.S. District Judge David Nye wrote in his brief, 9-page decision granting a temporary restraining order.

Highlighting the tentative nature of the ruling, Nye at one point referred to it as a “pre-preliminary” ruling — reasoning that a final judgement in challengers’ favor would permanently apply; a preliminary injunction would be … preliminary; and this, the TRO, is pre-preliminary.

The order from Nye — a Trump appointee who was initially nominated under the Obama administration — was ultimately a narrow ruling that preserves the status quo “as it existed prior to the parties’ disagreement” by keeping the new law on hold for now.

In that sense, Nye’s order stands in contrast — as an exercise in judicial minimalism — to the decision of a panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit earlier this summer allowing Tennessee’s ban on gender-affirming medical care for minors to go into effect. In that decision, the 2-1 panel majority similarly concluded that it was uncertain of the ultimate outcome of the case — but, despite the effect on minors’ medical care, the majority there upended the status quo by allowing the ban to go into effect.

In the Idaho case, a transgender student and high school student group sued in the state in July — represented by Lambda Legal; Alturas Law Group; and Munger, Tolles, and Olson — days after the law went into effect.

Notably, the Department of Justice weighed in earlier this week with a “statement of interest” filing supporting the challenge.

The United States therefore respectfully submits this Statement of Interest, under 28 U.S.C. § 517,3 to advise the Court of its view that Title IX and the Equal Protection Clause do not permit Idaho to categorically exclude transgender students from using public schools’ multi-user, singlesex facilities consistent with their gender identity.4

On that question — the substance of whether the state’s new law is constitutional or not — Nye, effectively, punted. Discussing the circuit split that Law Dork covered last week in discussing the recent ruling of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit (which, itself, is referenced in Nye’s opinion), Nye hedged — for now.

Notably, there is already a circuit split on the issues raised in this case. The Fourth Circuit has decided that denying gender-affirming bathroom access can violate both Title IX and the Equal Protection Clause, while the Eleventh Circuit found no violations based on substantially similar facts. Compare Grimm v. Gloucester County School Board, 972 F.3d 586 (4th Cir. 2020), with Adams ex rel. Kasper v. School Board of St. Johns County, 57 F.4th 791 (11th Cir. 2022) (en banc). And just last week, the Seventh Circuit effectively joined the Fourth Circuit when it upheld preliminary injunctions entered in two district court cases dealing with these same issues. See A.C. by M.C. v. Metro. Sch. Dist. of Martinsville, 2023 WL 4881915 (7th Cir. Aug. 1, 2023). Candidly, against this divided backdrop, the Court does not know if Plaintiffs will be able to show success on the merits or not at the upcoming hearing. Hence the Court’s focus today on the status quo. Ultimately, the Court finds the Winter factors do not tip strongly one way or the other. The Court does find, however, that preserving the status quo pending a more complete review is the most fitting approach at the current juncture.

As “the most fitting approach,” Nye chose to issue the temporary restraining order.

“School districts may choose how to organize their bathrooms, changing facilities, and overnight accommodations—whether that is sex-separate or transgender-inclusive; whether it is consistent with what it did last year or not,” he concluded. “But the State of Idaho will not be mandating that decision at this time.”

VI. ORDER 1. Plaintiffs’ Motion for Temporary Restraining Order (Dkt. 34) is GRANTED. 2. The provisions of S.B. 1100 are held in abeyance until the Court has an opportunity to rule on the merits of this action. 3. The TRO will last until the Court issues a decision on Plaintiffs’ PI Motion unless ordered otherwise. DATED: August 10, 2023  _________________________ David C. Nye Chief U.S. District Court Judge

The TRO will remain in effect until the court rules on the preliminary injunction request, absent some other unexpected order. A hearing on the preliminary injunction request is currently set for Sept. 13.

Law Dork covers LGBTQ legal issues in depth. Subscribe today.

57
Share this post

Federal judge puts Idaho schools bathroom ban on hold before new school year starts

www.lawdork.com
8
Share
Previous
Next
8 Comments
Share this discussion

Federal judge puts Idaho schools bathroom ban on hold before new school year starts

www.lawdork.com
Ian Mark Sirota
Writes Ian’s Substack
Aug 12

Good on the judge.

Expand full comment
Reply
Share
Amato DeLuca
Aug 12

The courts are now split because they don’t know how the Supreme Court will rule on this issue so some would rather be safe than sorry. Equality is evasive and is becoming an oxymoron. It’s almost like we starting all over.

Expand full comment
Reply
Share
6 more comments...
Top
New
Community

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Chris Geidner
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing